Revisiting Rivalries: The Johnstown Tomahawks and Their Legendary Matchups

Johnstown Tomahawks

From heated on-ice battles to intense fan rivalries, hockey has always sparked strong emotions among its followers. And when it comes to rivalries, few come close to the intensity and history of the matchups between the Johnstown Tomahawks and their opponents. As one of the oldest and most successful teams in the North American Hockey League (HL), the Tomahawks have built a rich history of competition and camaraderie on and off the ice. In this article, we take a closer look at some of the Tomahawks’ most important matchups and the stories behind them.

Early Days: The Tomahawks vs the Soo Eagles

Founded in 2012, the Johnstown Tomahawks quickly made a name for themselves in the HL with their fast-paced, aggressive style of play. And in their very first season, the Tomahawks found themselves facing off against the Soo Eagles, a fierce rival from Sault Ste. Marie, Michigan.

The two teams had a lot in common – both were new to the league and were looking to make a mark. The Tomahawks, led by head coach Jason Spence, were determined to prove themselves as a force to be reckoned with. And the Soo Eagles, coached by Bruno Bragagnolo, were equally determined to show their dominance on the ice.

The games between the Tomahawks and the Eagles were fast, physical, and often unpredictable. The teams were evenly matched and every game was a battle to the very end. The rivalry between the two teams quickly gained traction, as fans from both sides eagerly cheered on their teams and engaged in friendly banter (and sometimes not so friendly) with their rivals.

The intensity of the Tomahawks-Eagles rivalry was evident on the ice, but what made it truly special was the mutual respect and admiration between the players and the coaches. Despite their fierce competition, the Tomahawks and the Eagles formed a bond off the ice, often sharing meals and conversations, making the rivalry a positive and memorable experience for everyone involved.

A Turning Point: The Tomahawks vs the Michigan Warriors

The Tomahawks-Eagles rivalry may have been intense, but it paled in comparison to the showdowns between the Tomahawks and the Michigan Warriors. The Warriors had been a dominant force in the league, winning the division title in each of their first two seasons. And the Tomahawks, determined to make their mark as a top team, had their sights set on taking down their fierce competitors.

The two teams faced each other in the playoffs in the Tomahawks’ third season, with the series tied at two games apiece. The stage was set for a thrilling Game 5 to determine who would advance to the next round. The Tomahawks’ home arena was packed with over 3,000 passionate fans, creating an electric atmosphere that would only add to the drama on the ice.

The game was a back-and-forth affair, with both teams giving their all. In the end, it was the Tomahawks who came out on top, winning by a score of 2-1. The win marked a turning point for the Tomahawks, as they went on to reach the division finals for the first time in franchise history.

The rivalry between the Tomahawks and the Warriors was fierce, but it was also one of respect and sportsmanship. To this day, players and coaches from both teams hold each other in high regard, acknowledging the role their rival played in making them better competitors.

A New Era: The Tomahawks vs the New Jersey Titans

As the Tomahawks continued to establish themselves as a top team in the league, a new rivalry emerged – this time against the New Jersey Titans. The Titans had only joined the league in the 2016-2017 season, but they wasted no time in making themselves known as a formidable opponent.

The two teams faced each other in the playoffs in the Tomahawks’ sixth season, and what followed was an intense series that would further fuel the rivalry between the two teams. The Tomahawks, determined to prove they were the superior team, took the first two games of the series at home, sending a clear message to their opponents.

But the Titans were not out of the fight yet. They pulled off a stunning 4-1 victory in Game 3, followed by a close 3-2 win in Game 4, tying the series and forcing a pivotal Game 5 in New Jersey. With tensions running high and both teams giving their all, the Tomahawks emerged victorious, clinching the series and moving on to the next round.

The rivalry between the Tomahawks and the Titans continues to be one of the most exciting and intense matchups in the HL. As the two teams face each other season after season, the matchup only grows in significance and history, adding to the storied legacy of the Johnstown Tomahawks.


The Johnstown Tomahawks have faced many worthy opponents in their nearly decade-long history, but it is the rivalries they have built along the way that have truly defined their legacy. Whether it’s the intense battles against the Soo Eagles, the pivotal series against the Michigan Warriors, or the ongoing showdowns against the New Jersey Titans, the Tomahawks have left an indelible mark on the HL and on the hearts of hockey fans everywhere.


Johnstown Tomahawks,


hockey rivalries